Fan Spins, but Your Equipment is Still Overheating? Let's Talk Cooling Fan Motor Relays

Your equipment temperature is climbing, threatening a costly shutdown. You check the enclosure and see the fan spinning, but it’s doing nothing. Fan Motor

A spinning fan doesn't always mean effective cooling. The problem might be hidden in the airflow path, the fan’s own limitations, or a faulty component like a motor relay that seems to be working but isn't.

This situation is more common than you think. I've seen it countless times in my career working with major clients like Siemens and ABB. A simple check can often save thousands in downtime. Let's dig deeper and move beyond just looking at the fan to find the root cause of your overheating problem.
Is the fan really cooling "effectively"? Have you checked these three points?
A spinning blade is not a guarantee of proper cooling. I remember a case at a manufacturing plant where their new system kept tripping on high temperature. The fan was spinning, brand new. The issue? It was installed backward, pulling hot air into the cabinet. It's an easy mistake to make. Effective cooling is about moving the right amount of air in the right direction. If the fan is undersized for the heat load generated by your PLCs, VFDs, and power supplies, it will fight a losing battle. Or, if the fan bearings are worn, the motor might spin, but the blades won't achieve their rated RPM, drastically reducing airflow. It’s crucial to verify these basics before you start blaming more complex components.

Has the actual temperature of your environment exceeded the fan's design limits?

This is a point many engineers overlook, especially when specifying equipment for facilities in different climates. I worked on a project for an installation in the Middle East. The engineer in Europe had specified a standard fan that worked perfectly in his 20°C (68°F) lab. But on-site, the ambient temperature inside the facility regularly hit 45°C (113°F). The fan was spinning, but it was just circulating very hot air. A fan's purpose is to replace the hot air inside the cabinet with cooler, ambient air from outside. If the "cooler" outside air is already at or above the maximum operating temperature of your components, the fan is simply not going to work. It has nothing cool to work with. Every fan and every piece of electronic equipment has a maximum ambient operating temperature listed on its datasheet. Exceeding this is a recipe for failure.

Do you know your fan's maximum operating temperature?

Check the fan's datasheet. This value is critical. It tells you the highest ambient temperature at which the fan is guaranteed to perform as specified. If your environment exceeds this, you need a different cooling solution, perhaps a higher-temperature rated fan or even an enclosure air conditioner. Don't assume all fans are created equal. A standard commercial fan might be rated for 40°C, while a fan designed for rugged industrial or outdoor applications might be rated for 70°C or higher.

How does high ambient temperature impact cooling performance?

The cooling capacity of a fan is based on the temperature difference (ΔT) between the inside of the cabinet and the outside ambient air. For example, if your fan needs to keep the cabinet at 40°C and the ambient air is 25°C, you have a 15°C difference to work with. If the ambient air rises to 35°C, you now only have a 5°C difference. The fan has to work much harder and move much more air to achieve the same amount of cooling. If the ambient temperature reaches 40°C, the ΔT is zero. No cooling is possible.

Are you accounting for seasonal and local heat sources?

The environment is not static.

Factor	Consideration	Action
Summer Heat	The temperature inside a non-air-conditioned factory or an outdoor enclosure can be significantly higher in the summer.	You must design your cooling system for the worst-case, hottest-day scenario, not the yearly average.
Local Heat Sources	Is your electrical cabinet located next to a furnace, a large motor, or in direct sunlight?	These external heat sources add to the ambient temperature the fan has to deal with. Shield the cabinet or move it if possible.
Altitude	Air is less dense at higher altitudes.	A fan will move less air (lower CFM) at 3,000 meters than it does at sea level, reducing its cooling effectiveness. You may need a more powerful fan.

Always consider the real-world environment, not just the ideal conditions on paper.

tag #axial fan #cooling fan

News